How to evaluate the quality of information in five easy steps:
Authority
- Is the author a qualified expert in the field?
- What is her/his occupation, position, education, experience?
- What are her/his credentials?
- Who endorsed or published the information?
- What is the purpose of publication? Does the material inform? Explain? Persuade?
- Are assumptions, personal bias and opinions clearly stated?
- Is information presented in a clear and reasonable fashion?
- Are conclusions supported by facts?
- Is the site supported by advertising or run by a business?
- Is the author affiliated with particular organizations, institutions, or associations?
- What were the author's sources?
- Was the work peer reviewed and/or edited?
- Is the work free of grammatical and typographical errors?
- Do facts and conclusions check out with other reputable sources?
- When was the work written and published?
- Are the author's sources up-to-date?
- Has the information been updated or revised?
- Is there provision for corrective feedback to the author?
- Is it clear what topics are covered?
- Are they covered in sufficient depth?
- What is their relevance to your research?
No comments:
Post a Comment